Windows 365 vs. Azure Virtual Desktop (AVD) – Comparing Two DaaS Products in Lane Countyadmin
information source: Tony-Getnerdio and Microsoft.
Windows 365 vs. Azure Virtual Desktop (AVD) – Comparing Two DaaS Products in Eugene, Oregon
The recently released Microsoft Windows 365 service and Azure Virtual Desktop (AVD) are both Desktop-as-a-Service solutions from Microsoft but there are several important differences between them. In this article, we’ll take a deep dive into the similarities and differences between the services. We’ll compare AVD and Windows 365 across several dimensions in detail and then summarize it all together in a side-by-side chart. Let’s take a look at the two services across 5 primary areas:
IT Admin Experience
Licensing and Infrastructure Costs
Cloud PC License Cost vs. AVD Azure Consumption
1. Technical Architecture
Under-the-hood, both AVD and Windows 365 leverage a similar set of Microsoft cloud technologies. Technically, Windows 365 is built on top of existing AVD components but has a different transactional model (fixed price vs. consumption-based).
There are two versions of cloud PCs: Enterprise and Business.
Enterprise cloud PCs are designed for organizations who have invested into Microsoft Endpoint Manager and are using this powerful platform to manage their existing, physical Windows 10 desktops. Enterprise cloud PCs require an Intune license for each user who is assigned a cloud PC M365 SKU.
Business cloud PCs are designed for individual users and very small businesses who typically go to their local Best Buy when they need a new PC. Now, instead of visiting Best Buy, they can go to Microsoft and subscribe to a new cloud PC and have it ready to use in an hour. Business cloud PCs do not require an Intune license and are managed entirely by the user, similar to a standalone physical PC.
The diagram below depicts the deployment architecture of both Enterprise and Business cloud PCs.
Enterprise Cloud PC Architecture
Enterprise cloud PCs are Azure and Active Directory dependent. An Azure subscription with a properly configured network is required with access to Active Directory that has Azure AD Hybrid Join enabled. Azure AD DS is not currently supported and cloud-only, Azure AD join is not currently supported either.
The VM itself runs in a Microsoft-managed Azure subscription, which means admins don’t have access to it directly and are not incurring the cost of this VM in their own Azure subscription. However, the VM’s network interface card (NIC) is “injected” into a vNet in a customer’s Azure subscription. All network traffic enters and leaves the VM via the customer-managed vNet. Egress transfer costs are incurred by the customer.
Since admins don’t have direct access to the VM running in Microsoft’s Azure subscription, all management tasks (e.g. software installation, patching, policies) are performed through the Microsoft Endpoint Manager portal.
Enterprise cloud PC pre-requisites:
Azure subscription with vNet
Azure vNet can access Active Directory domain controller (i.e. a PC can be joined to the domain). Custom DNS servers, necessary routing, and firewall access to AD.
Azure AD Connect configured and running within Active Directory with AAD Hybrid Join enabled
Intune enabled on Azure AD tenant (each cloud PC user needs and Intune license assigned)
Admin setting up the initial deployment must be an Owner of this Azure subscription
Azure AD DS is NOT supported
Enterprise cloud PC high-level setup steps (without Nerdio Manager):
In Microsoft Endpoint Manager create an “on-premises network connection” pointing at the vNet and provide AD credentials to join new VMs. The network connection and AD credentials will be validated automatically. This process may take a while to complete.
Upload an existing custom Windows 10 Enterprise image or use a clean Microsoft-provided gallery image
Create a cloud PC “provisioning policy” that combines an “on-premises network connection” with a desktop image. Assign this provisioning policy to an Azure AD security group.
Add users to the Azure AD security group that the provisioning policy is assigned to
Enterprise cloud PC user entitlement
Once the above pre-requisites and setup steps are completed, entitling a user to a cloud PC is very easy. Simply assign a cloud PC license to the user via the Windows 365 Admin portal.
If the user is a member of a security group that’s assigned to a cloud PC provisioning policy and the network connection is “healthy,” a new cloud PC will start provisioning. It will take up to an hour for the cloud PC to be ready for the user to log into.
Business Cloud PC Architecture
Business cloud PCs are VMs that run entirely in Microsoft’s Azure subscription, including the network interface cards. The customer does not need to provide an Azure subscription. There is no Active Directory dependency since Business cloud PCs natively join Azure AD. There is also no requirement of an Intune license.
Business cloud PCs route all traffic through Microsoft-controlled network infrastructure and there is no way for admins to control the inbound or outbound connectivity to/from these VMs. There is currently no way to assign static IPs to Business cloud PCs. Since these cloud PCs run in Microsoft’s Azure subscription and are not enrolled in Intune, there is no admin interface to manage them. They can only be managed directly by the user, just like a standalone physical Windows device.
There are no pre-requisites and no setup steps needed for Business cloud PCs. Simply assign a Business cloud PC license to a user in the Windows 365 Admin portal and the new desktop gets provisioned within an hour. The user will get an email notification with login instructions to start using their new cloud PC.
1a – Control Plane
Azure Virtual Desktop and Windows 365 share the same global control plane running in Azure. The control plane consists of things such as the web portal, gateway, connection broker, licensing, and diagnostics service. All components are hosted and managed by Microsoft and admins interact with them via a portal or API while end-users interact with them via the AVD and cloud PC client apps.
An agent application runs on each virtual desktop – AVD session hosts and Windows 365 cloud PCs. This agent is responsible for communication with the Microsoft-managed control plane. Microsoft manages the agent and updates it automatically. The agent for both AVD and Windows 365 appear to be the same.
1b – Azure Subscriptions
Azure Virtual Desktop requires all session host VMs, FSLogix profile storage, and networking to be contained in a customer’s Azure subscription. Microsoft manages the control plane components, while the customer is fully responsible for everything related to the session host VMs. Costs are also incurred for all components based on usage at the customer subscription level.
With Windows 365, all compute (i.e. VMs) is contained in a Microsoft-managed Azure subscription. This means that customers don’t have direct access to manage the VM resources, as they do with AVD, since these resources are not accessible in their Azure subscription. They also don’t incur the costs associated with running cloud PC VMs at the Azure subscription level (more on this below).
There is a significant difference between Windows 365 Enterprise cloud PCs and Business cloud PCs. Enterprise cloud PCs run in Microsoft’s Azure subscription, but their network interface cards (virtual NICs) are “injected” into the customer’s Azure subscription. Business cloud PC VMs reside entirely within Microsoft’s Azure subscription with no components connected to any customer Azure subscription.
1c – Compute
Azure Virtual Desktop session hosts are regular VMs and can be deployed and used in a very flexible way with all the power of Azure. These session hosts can serve up personal desktops, where a VM is dedicated to a single user, or pooled desktops where a VM can be used by multiple users who move between such VMs daily. The cost of compute is incurred by the customer since these VMs run in the customer’s Azure subscription. Since pricing for Azure compute is based on usage, auto-scaling can be used to significantly reduce the cost of VMs in an AVD environment. Reserved Instances can also be used with AVD session host VMs.
A Windows 365 cloud PC is a VM that’s dedicated to a single user via permanent assignment (like personal desktops in AVD). These VMs run in Microsoft’s Azure subscription, which means the customer is not responsible for the compute costs. They are licensed via a Windows 365 cloud PC license and are based on a fixed per-user-per-month price. Since IT admins don’t have access to these VMs directly from the Azure portal and the cost doesn’t depend on usage, concepts like auto-scaling and reserved instances don’t apply to cloud PCs.
1d – Storage
Azure Virtual Desktop session host VMs must have an OS disk attached to them. These disks can be any Azure managed disk type (e.g. Premium SSD, Standard SSD or Standard HDD) and even an Ephemeral OS disk. IT admins have full flexibility when it comes to the size and type of OS disk to use. Auto-scaling can be leveraged to convert SSD disks to cheaper HDD disks while VMs are powered off.
FSLogix profiles are typically stored in Azure Files shares, Azure NetApp Files volumes, or file server VMs. Here too, IT admins have full flexibility around the type of storage and the size of storage to use in the AVD deployment, including what to back up and how. All storage costs associated with session host OS disks and FSLogix profile storage are incurred by the customer via the Azure subscription.
Each Windows 365 cloud PC comes with a pre-defined amount of local SSD storage. The cost of this storage is included in the cloud PC M365 license, and the OS disk object is located within Microsoft’s Azure subscription, which means the customer is not responsible for any Azure storage costs. There is no flexibility around what type of storage to use and using auto-scaling is not possible since the cost is fixed. FSLogix is not used with Windows 365 cloud PCs and user profiles are “native” and reside fully on the C: drive of the desktop. This means that no additional Azure Files, Azure NetApp Files, or file server VMs are needed. There are limited backup and DR options available for now with cloud PCs.
1e – Networking
Azure Virtual Desktop network routing and security is fully under the control of IT admins. Session hosts are regular VMs that can be created on any virtual network in the customer’s Azure subscription and this vNet can be configured with all the flexibility of Azure networking. This means that customers have full control of how ingress and egress traffic is routed, what IP addresses are used, VPN connectivity, etc. They are also responsible for any costs associated with egress bandwidth usage.
The network configuration of cloud PCs depends on whether they are Enterprise or Business. Enterprise cloud PCs have the same capabilities, from a networking perspective, as AVD session hosts. The vNet that they attach to resides within the customer’s Azure subscription and is fully controlled by the IT admin. Network interfaces of cloud PCs are “injected” into the customer’s Azure subscription even though the VM resources they are attached to are in a different subscription. Just like with AVD, all costs associated with networking are incurred by the customer.
Business cloud PCs don’t have the same network flexibility as Enterprise ones. Their network interfaces are not injected into a vNet in the customer’s Azure subscription but are part of a Microsoft-managed network. This means that routing, firewall security, VPN connectivity, and IP addressing cannot be controlled by the customer. The costs of egress bandwidth usage are not customer’s responsibility and are included in the cost of licensing a cloud PC (more on this below).
1f – User Profiles
Azure Virtual Desktop leverages FSLogix profile container technology. This allows users to roam from one session host VM to another while their user profile (contents of c:\users\username folder) follows them seamlessly. FSLogix provides lots of flexibility but comes at the cost of having to deploy at least one SMB file share to host the profile container VHD(X) files. This is typically done with Azure Files, Azure NetApp Files, or file server VMs.
Because Windows 365 cloud PCs are single-session desktops dedicated to individual users, Microsoft removed FSLogix from the picture. A user’s Windows profile is “native”, meaning that it is stored directly on the C: drive of the cloud PC, exactly as is with traditional, physical Windows computers. This removes the complexity of having to configure and manage FSLogix and the associated overhead of having a SMB file share to store profiles centrally. It also introduces some unique challenges in protecting users’ data (e.g. Documents and Desktop folders) and moving users from one desktop to another without losing settings.
1g – Identity
Azure Virtual Desktop currently requires Active Directory Domain Services. This requirement can be fulfilled by using an existing Windows AD environment or by using the Azure AD DS PaaS service. Native Azure AD join isn’t yet supported, but upcoming support was recently announced.
Windows 365 Enterprise cloud PCs require Hybrid Azure AD join. This means that you need traditional Windows AD synched to Azure AD with Hybrid Join enabled. Azure AD DS is not currently supported.
Business cloud PCs are natively Azure AD joined and do not require (or support) Windows AD or Azure AD DS.
Summary (Technical Architecture)
2. IT Admin Experience
The IT admin experience varies greatly between Windows 365 and Azure Virtual Desktop. AVD relies heavily on Azure management concepts and provides maximum flexibility while Windows 365 aims to simplify management by making it (close to) identical to managing existing physical desktop assets and leveraging the same set of Microsoft tools to manage physical and virtual PCs.
2a – Management Portal
All components of Azure Virtual Desktop are managed via the Azure portal, PowerShell, or third-party tools like the Nerdio Manager.
Enterprise cloud PCs are managed via Microsoft Endpoint Manager (MEM) and via the Azure portal for all networking. Administration of Enterprise cloud PCs can also be unified via a single portal like the Nerdio Manager. MEM allows management of cloud PCs at the OS level and above. This means that admins do not have access to make changes to the underlying VM resources, they can only make changes to Windows and applications. Virtual networking is managed via the Azure portal.
Business cloud PCs are not integrated with Endpoint Manager and do not have a dedicated management portal. They can only be managed by the end user assigned to the desktop while logged into it. Actions such as PC restarts can be performed by the user from the cloud PC web portal. Admins can manage Business cloud PC license assignment with Windows 365 Admin portal and third-party tools like the Nerdio Manager.
2b – Operating System
Azure Virtual Desktop supports all current versions of Windows, including Windows 10 Enterprise (single session), EVD (multi-session) and Server 2012/2016/2019.
Windows 365 cloud PCs only support Windows 10 Enterprise (single session) since they are dedicated, non-multi-user desktops.
2c – Desktop Image Management
Azure Virtual Desktop can leverage all image types. These include Azure Marketplace images, custom images, and shared image gallery images. Session host VMs can be created from these images and be kept up to date by updating the image and then re-imaging session hosts to the latest version. Images can be stored in one or more Azure regions for geographic distribution and resilience. Images can use any supported operating system and be both Gen1 and Gen2 VM hardware. There is no limit on the number of Azure images that can be used in an AVD environment.
Enterprise cloud PC images support Microsoft-provided Windows 10 Enterprise OS or custom images stored in a customer’s subscription. These images must be Gen1 VM hardware. There is a limit of 20 custom images per Azure AD tenant.
Business cloud PCs don’t support custom images and must be deployed from Microsoft provided Windows 10 Enterprise OS.
2d – Applications and Updates
Azure Virtual Desktop session hosts can be updated via Microsoft Endpoint Manager, through a golden image, or manually. Applications can be delivered to session hosts via image updates, manual installation on host VMs, or using MSIX app attach. The update and application delivery process in AVD is very flexible and can be fully automated.
Enterprise cloud PCs can be updated via MEM or manual methods. Image-based software deployments are not typical without third-party tools like Nerdio Manager. Also, MSIX app attach application delivery is not currently supported with cloud PCs.
Business cloud PCs can be updated with Windows update, manually by the user, or by using third-party management tools.
2e – Backup and DR
Azure Virtual Desktop session hosts can be backed up and protected in several different ways including Azure Site Recovery and Azure Backup. This allows organizations to create a robust backup, DR, and business continuity strategy for their virtual desktop environment.
There is currently no native backup method for Windows 365 cloud PCs since they are not accessible to admins at the storage or hypervisor level. Third-party, agent-based, OS-level backup methods can be used to protect cloud PCs.
2f – Monitoring
Azure Virtual Desktop includes robust logging, diagnostics, monitoring, and reporting capabilities. Logs are generated by the AVD service and AVD agent running on session host VMs. This information is streamed to Azure Log Analytics where it is captured and visualized with Azure Monitor workbooks. Many third-party monitoring tools are available for AVD.
Due to the lack of hypervisor-level access to cloud PC VMs, monitoring is possible only via Endpoint Analytics, which is the same tool that can be used for monitoring physical endpoints. Business cloud PCs do not currently have a monitoring interface.
2g – User Profiles
Azure Virtual Desktop leverages FSLogix for user profile encapsulation. This allows users to easily roam between session host VMs without losing their user state between sessions. Personal AVD desktops can be deployed without FSLogix, but even in persistent scenarios FSLogix profiles provide a valuable profile backup capability and make it easier to manage session host updates through images. A SMB file share is required to host the FSLogix profile containers. This can be an Azure Files share, Azure NetApp Files volume, or a file server VM.
Windows 365 cloud PCs do not leverage FSLogix and all profiles are natively stored on the C: drive. This allows for simplified management since no additional SMB storage or profile configuration is required. Without profile data redirection it is important to consider ways to back up user data. One such strategy can leverage OneDrive to protect user data.
2h – Networking
IT admins fully control all aspects of Azure Virtual Desktop networking since it runs in a customer-managed Azure subscription. Static IP addresses can be assigned, VPN tunnels configured, and firewall rules enforced.
Enterprise cloud PCs have the same network flexibility as in AVD deployments. Business cloud PCs, on the other hand, do not have any network flexibility. Microsoft fully controls the IP addressing, traffic flow, and security of Business cloud PC networking.
2i – Auto-Scaling
Azure Virtual Desktop greatly benefits from usage-based Azure pricing model and auto-scale can be used to drastically reduce Azure compute and storage costs – up to 75% of peak demand. It is also possible to use Azure Reserved Instances to reduce costs and guarantee available capacity.
Windows 365 cloud PCs are priced on a fixed monthly basis. Even if a user does not log into their desktop at all during the month, the desktop will cost the same as if the user logged into their desktop every day. Therefore, the concept of auto-scaling does not apply to cloud PCs. This has significant impact on cost efficiency in different use-cases.
Summary (IT Admin Experience)
3. End-user Experience
The end-user experience is almost identical in Windows 365 and AVD. Users connect to AVD sessions and cloud PCs using the same client app, which is available for Windows, MacOS, iOS, Android and as a HTML client.
Windows 365 is built on top of Azure Virtual Desktop global infrastructure and will be familiar to those with AVD experience. When connecting to a cloud PC, a user authenticates to Azure AD using the AVD client and all cloud PCs that the user is entitled to appear in the feed.
Leveraging the same infrastructure as AVD provides users the advantage of a unified experience across Windows 365 and Azure Virtual Desktop. Admins can control the resources visible to individual end-users and the user will see everything in a single feed using the same app. The authentication and multi-factor experience will also be very familiar since it leverages Azure AD, which is used for M365 and AVD authentication.
3a – Connecting to Desktop
With Azure Virtual Desktop, users navigate to https://aka.ms/wvdwebarm or download a client app from https://aka.ms/wvdclients.
Windows 365 cloud PC users navigate to https://cloudpc.microsoft.com and connect in the same way as AVD.
Step 1: Go to https://cloudpc.microsoft.com and log in
Step 2: Connect to cloud PC in the browser or download the Remote Desktop client app
📷3b – Printing and Scanning
Both Azure Virtual Desktop and Windows 365 cloud PCs support printer and scanner redirection via the Remote Desktop client app. With AVD and Enterprise cloud PCs it is possible to configure network-based printing and scanning with a site-to-site VPN tunnel between the Azure vNet and local network that hosts the printers and scanners. It is not possible to use network-based printing and scanning with Business cloud PCs since IT admins do not have control of the network where the cloud PCs reside. Universal Print is Microsoft’s new cloud-based print solution that can be used with AVD and Windows 365 cloud PCs. Several third-party products exist that help simplifies printing and scanning.
3c – User self-service
Azure Virtual Desktop has limited self-service capabilities for end-users. For example, users cannot restart their own desktop VM or log off a hung session with the AVD client app. Third-party tools, like Nerdio Manager, provide users with a self-service portal where such actions can be performed.
Windows 365 cloud PCs can be restarted by the end-user without the need to contact support. A restart button is built into the cloud PC web portal.
Summary (End-user Experience)
4. Licensing and Infrastructure Costs
4a – Windows 10 Enterprise
Azure Virtual Desktop requires the user connecting to an AVD session to have an assigned Windows 10 Enterprise subscription license. Windows 10 Enterprise can be purchased as a standalone subscription (e.g. Windows 10 Ent E3/E5/VDA) or be included as part of a Windows 365 suite subscription (e.g. M365 E3/E5 and Business Premium). This Windows subscription license includes the usage rights of the AVD control plane and entitles the user to connect to Windows 10 desktops hosted in Azure. All other costs are part of Azure infrastructure consumption (e.g. compute, storage, networking).
Both Enterprise and Business Windows 365 cloud PCs require a Windows 10 Enterprise subscription just like AVD desktops. However, the compute costs are not purchased as usage-based Azure resources but rather as a M365 license SKU.
4b – Compute and Storage
Azure Virtual Desktop infrastructure costs are based on Azure consumption. This includes the compute costs of running AVD session host VMs, the cost of OS disks and the usage of Azure Files for FSLogix storage. All costs are based on actual usage. If a VM is powered off, there is no compute charge.
Windows 365 cloud PCs are not purchased as Azure usage-based infrastructure. Rather, they are purchased as licenses through Windows 365. Each cloud PC license provides the user with a certain amount of compute, RAM, and storage capacity. At general availability there will be 12 cloud PC sizes ranging from 1 vCPU to 8 vCPUs, 2 GB to 32 GB of RAM, and 64 GB to 512 GB of storage.
4c – Networking
Azure Virtual Desktop networking costs are incurred at the Azure subscription level where session host VMs run. These charges typically include egress bandwidth, NAT gateway, VPNs, and Firewalls.
Enterprise cloud PCs require the customer to provide a network infrastructure within a customer-managed Azure subscription. Therefore, all network costs are the same as with AVD.
Business cloud PCs do not leverage a customer-managed Azure network. Therefore, all network related costs are incurred by Microsoft and are included in the monthly cloud PC license.
4d – Intune
Intune can be optionally used to manage Azure Virtual Desktop session hosts. However, Intune is not required for an AVD deployment, and most environments are managed via images.
Enterprise cloud PCs require an Intune license. Since Intune is the management interface for these cloud PCs, the Azure AD tenant must have an Intune license and each user who is assigned to an Enterprise cloud PC must have an Intune license assigned. Intune licenses can be purchased standalone or as part of a Windows 365 package like E3/E5 and Business Premium.
Business cloud PCs are not managed through MEM and therefore do not require an Intune license.
4e – Windows 365 Apps (Office)
Azure Virtual Desktop requires a subscription to Windows 365 Apps with Shared Computer Activation entitlement. All Windows 365 packages that include Office Apps have Shared Computer Activation. Windows 365 Business standalone does not and, therefore, cannot be used in AVD.
Windows 365 cloud PCs are dedicated VMs and therefore do not require Shared Computer Activation. Any subscription to Windows 365 is sufficient.
Summary (Licensing and Infrastructure Costs)
5. Comparing Windows 365 Cloud PC License Costs vs. AVD Azure Consumption
There are several considerations that come into play when deciding on the right virtual desktop technology for your organization. Microsoft provides customers with ample choice and meets customers where they are in terms of admin tooling, existing licenses, and Azure expertise. In this section we’ll explore the cost efficiency of different virtual desktop use-cases and determine when Windows 365 fixed-price licenses are more cost-efficient than usage-based AVD infrastructure costs. For this discussion, we’ll assume that licensing costs are the same in both AVD and cloud PC scenarios and focus exclusively on the cost of the infrastructure.
Once Microsoft releases finalized Windows 365 cloud PC pricing, a detailed side-by-side cost comparison will be published in this section.
Here’s a complete comparative summary table: